The Snape Hater Club
johnbowman19
jhnbwmn at hotmail.com
Wed Jul 20 05:17:42 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 133369
My reading of the HBP turned me into a Snape hater. I used to enjoy
the literary genius of Harry's black and white hatred of Snape until
I read the OOTP. Their relationship gained a deeper level with
Harry's trip into Snape's Worst Memory. We saw the human side to
Serverus, and had to wonder what kind of a person Harry's father had
been, now after the HBP, we have to wonder what kind of person Snape
is.
I know there have been many posts theorizing whether DD planned for
Snape to kill him as a way for Snape to become Voldemort's 2nd in
command, but to them I say this: what kind of character would kill
the only person who has treated that character with nothing but
trust and friendship? DD was the only person to stick by SS, he kept
SS out of prison, He defended him to the Order, and he gave SS a
job. What kind of person would be able to kill DD after DD had done
all that for them even if it was part of DD plan? The answer is
simple: a Death Eater could.
Snape took from me my favorite character, and for that I
vilify him. DD always believed the best in everyone, and surly that
was his downfall with Snape, but can we fault DD for Snapes actions?
DD pleaded with Snape, and yet he was cold blooded enough to kill
him like a dog in the dirt. For this, Snape is, in my book, worthy
of death at the hands of Harry. In fact, I think I will start an I
hate Snape group here on Yahoo! Snape is pure evil and in my eyes,
should be treated as such for the reminder of the series.
John who will be gauging the responses to find out if opening up a
Snape hater club is worth it.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive