When did Snape invent his curses?

benigs benigs at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 20 07:43:26 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 133399

grega126 <grega126 at a...> wrote:
> The thing that's been bugging me about this whole him inventing 
> these curses thing, is how did James learn a non-verbal spell 
> that Snape had created.  Remus says that the curse was quite 
> the fad when they were in school.  So if Snape invented it, 
> someone else would've had to have also created it independent 
> of Snape, OR Snape didn't actually invent them, but he just 
> wrote them down in his book.


Well someone could have seen Snape do the curse before and of course 
asked him how it was done... And of course the curse could've spread 
like wildfire as it was so "cool" looking... Or maybe Snape thought 
of the curse before he even learned how to do non-verbal spells and 
people would've heard it and copied it...

Benigs








More information about the HPforGrownups archive