Evil Snape? I think not.

[hogwartsmom]

No: HPFGUIDX 133588

Jazmyn Concolor <jazmyn at p...> wrote:

He worked too hard to keep the other DEs from killing Harry too, when
he could have just let one of them kill him and then let LV deal with
the person who killed Harry. . He also was still trying to teach Harry
to the last.


HogwartsMom says:

This is an excellent point.  I've been going over the two scenarios in
my mind since Sunday ((1) Snape is loyal to LV (2) Snape is loyal to
the Order)and haven't been able to find the one piece that makes the
puzzle go one way or the other.  

I was just DEVASTATED when Snape killed DD since I've believed he was
not a bad guy since book 1.  If (2) is the case, he is some kind of
really brave hero.  It all comes down to whether one has faith in DD's
judgement or not, doesn't it?

HogwartsMom