Snape's tragedy (was Snape Haters Club)

[lunamk03]

No: HPFGUIDX 133631

fourfuries at a... wrote:

> ...if you read the few excerpts available from the most recent interviews, it becomes patently obvious that Snape is evil. There is no way in the world for him to settle up with Harry. In fact, JKR says that it is now as personal between them as it is between Harry and Lord Thingy, if not more so. 

I have this little theory
 It just clicked to me when I was finishing
the book. It just added up! 
I think that Snape actually wants to ultimately kill Voldemort. This
goes so well with Jo's line of having not entirely good or bad
characters. He or someone related to him is the one that left the fake
thing in the bowl. I guess he might have made that magical, binding 
promise to this person and DD knew about it. Also I saw how he reacted
to Narcissa when she begged him for help
 Was he thinking about his
own mother? Did LV do something horrible to his mother? Did Snape
swear to kill him? Does Snape want his revenge? Is this the reason why
he joined the death eaters in the first place? This would give him the
glory and greatness we know he wants. He would surpass Harry's level
of fame. This would explain so many things!

This would explain why he's become such an accomplished Occlumens, he
needs to hide his true intentions from LV.  All this bitterness,
resentment and hate.. all this fascination for the dark arts


This would explain why he was all these years with DD and why DD
trusted him so much
 He was using DD to find the crux
well, you know,
the little pieces with LV souls in them. Snape hasn't attacked or
tried to kill Voldemort before because he knows there are these
objects that need to be neutralized before confronting him. He was
resentful and mad at DD because DD was becoming weak and was turning
to Harry the "boy who lived" to prepare him to kill LV instead of 
turning to him
 

This would also explain why he killed DD. Snape didn't need to have DD
alive to kill LV. Now more than ever he needs to be the closest he can
be to Voldemort, he knows what Harry knows, he doesn't want Harry to
take his revenge and glory away from him
 DD has become an annoyance
for his plans
 He needed to show LV his loyalty and what better way
than killing DD? He'll have back all of Voldemort's and death eaters'
trust.  He'll be the closest to Voldemort so he'll be the one to be
there first to kill him. 

This explains why he hates Harry so much. It isn't only about James,
it is also about the thread Harry represents for his plans of revenge.
I think at certain a point, Snape has concidered using Harry to get to
and kill LV.

 I see next book as a kind of race between Harry and Snape to kill LV

The reader will see it as Snape trying to protect Voldemort but, at
the end, his true intentions will be revealed, then we'll know about
Snape's personal tragedy
 Deep down Harry and Snape are going for the
same trophy. At the end they might have to reluctantly join forces to
do it and Snape will die in the intent. 

Luna, who thinks if this theory turns out to be true, she'll have to
appologize to Jo for being such a big mouth.