Dumbledore and the poison(?) potion

[saraquel_omphale]

No: HPFGUIDX 133643

> "ar_hp03" <ar_hp03 at y...> >wrote:
> I was just discussing Dumbledore's reaction after drinking the 
>potion
> at the cave with a friend and it suddenly struck me that his 
>reactions
> seem to be something similar to what we see when people face
> dementors, ie., being forced to re-live their worst memories. In >the
> book it appears that Dumbledore is somehow being forced to re-live 
>his
> worst memories.  
I think the potion is KEY to understanding what happens to DD 
afterwards and poses some VERY BIG questions about the locket.  For 
those interested in this line of enquiry, I have posted a TBAY.  Don't 
worry, if you can't stand TBAY speak,  the theory is written straight 
and is easy to find.  

Message 133414 : TBAY: DRASTIC LIST DREAD SINKING

It brings up some big questions which I'm not totally satisfied with 
how I've answered, but the big problem to me is that if RAB did 
substitute the locket, the potion in the bowl is his not Voldemort's.

Apoligies to the List Elves for effectively reposting my original 
post, something I'd never normally do. But I don't think people 
interested in the thread have picked it up, probably due to list 
volume.
Saraquel