Valky's confession; The Snape Hater Club

Jenserai Bariman jenserai at hotmail.com
Wed Jul 20 23:40:49 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 133670

nrenka says:
"On the rest of it, I'm beginning to find the "death was set up completely in advance" scenario 
more and more unlikely considering all the detailed plans DD is offering Draco; but that's 
another thread."

Jens (me) says:
"The plans may have simply been a method of getting Draco not to kill Dumbledore.  I think 
the assumption the characters are making is that Draco will not be killed if Snape completes 
his task for him.  Else-wise, why would Narcissa have asked Snape to do it?  She certainly 
seemed more concerned about her son's imminent doom than anything else.  By having 
Snape AK Dumbledore we now have a live, potentially redeemable Draco and Snape is in a 
better position than ever to help bring down Voldemort.  Obviously the question remains, is 
Snape planning to continue passing info to the order and if so, how?  But that too, is another 
discussion."

-Jens






More information about the HPforGrownups archive