Dumbledore's Last Act

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 133746

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ohnooboe" <hautbois1 at c...> wrote:
> SNIP!!!
> 
> > Doddiemoemoe wrote:
> 
> > Snape could have made short work of the DE's remaining on the 
> tower 
> > ledge and went into hiding with Draco and Fam. and perhaps even 
> > extend DD's life a little longer.  He didn't do it he chose to 
> kill 
> > DD..
> 
> Pat here!
> 
> I find myself longing for Snape not to be the "evil one" he's shown 
> himself to be in HBP...anyway...  Yes, doddie, Snape did have the 
> opportunity to not kill DD.  However, I don't think the option of 
> fleeing into the night with Draco existed.  
Doddiemoemoe here:

You are completely wrong....

If snape AK'd DD then he could do so throughout...

Snape could have killed and most definitely destroyed/disabled all DE's 
there that night, BUT,  Snape did not do it!!!

And Snape never Killed Harry.........instead....Snape..oh just 
wait...no he killed no DE's either...and we are positive Harry is no 
DE...but we never saw any DE challenge Snape!

Everyone believes he killed DD...

for LV it means Ssnape could do what he could not......awww bless 
nothing about Bellatrix but her little cotton socks..

for everyone...DE's and OOP's and everyone in between...the focus has 
shifted...MOM doesn't matter...and Hogwarts doesn't matter...

We are at the point that the war is entirely personal and based upon 
principal!!! (sad, yet true with most wars--aside from the star wars 
variety lol)..

If Hogwarts doesn't matter and MOM doesn't matter and the PM's office 
doesn't matter..then we truly begin the war on morals, values, and 
emotions...

Doddie

--whatch out Voldiemoldy!