The Horcrux that time forgot..

[queencrem]

No: HPFGUIDX 133780

Kathi:
>I am still convinced that Harry's scar is a horcrux.


Interesting theory and one that would certainly wow the readers at 
the end of book 7. Two problems though:

1. It's stated both in OotP and HBP that Voldemort can't exist 
inside Harry's body. Therefore, it remains unlikely part of his 
soul could either. Even if it could, knowing as Voldy does now 
that he can't live inside Harry (OotP at the DOM), he would have 
to organise an eighth Horcrux to naturally be his seventh once 
he kills Harry - so Harry would still have to identify an entirely 
new one and destroy it. We don't know if Voldemort is aware of the destruction of his diary, let alone the locket, which would excuse 
his not having created two further Horcruxes. But then I suppose 
the whole point is to have back up plans. 
REGARDLESS:
2. If Harry's scar were indeed a Horcrux he would have to kill 
himself before Voldemort could die, unless JKR plans on entering 
some seriously weird Face/Off parallels (doo doo doo doo - which 
one is Travolta/Cage/Potter???). Imagine if she killed Harry 
before Voldemort? She'd have a trillion fans out to AK her ass.

"queencrem"