Dumbledore's Wayward Conjectures

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 133834


lucinda428:
> > Whether you agree with that or not, the key point I'd like to 
> > highlight for debate is, at least one of Dumbledore's assumptions 
> > is wrong: which one?
> > 


Valky:

Big ask that lucinda, but definitely worth thinking about. The first
thing that comes to mind is that he was wrong about the Diary Horcrux
nd the destruction of the soul inside it.. Yes I know it's very sad
and tragic, and now everyone thinks I am so very sadistic to offhand
sentence lovely little Ginny to doom, but thats it, thats the one I
think it is. Having said that though, I am not actually sure that I
believe it was a mistake Dumbledore didn't realise before he died, in
fact sad as it seems I think he told Harry how big his mistakes were
*because* he'd realised that he didn't save Ginny when he might have
had a real chance to. Really really massive mistake, don't you think?