Dumbledore's Wayward Conjectures

[Marisa Crosset]

No: HPFGUIDX 133839

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "lucinda428" 
<lucinda428 at y...> wrote:

> That's why Lily was, in his opinion, being "a silly girl" to give 
> her life to protect him.  James's was the necessary death: 
Harry was 
> only ever to be a Horcrux spell.  It has been pointed out that this 
> spell did not emerge from Voldemort's wand in GOF - maybe 
he used 
> James's (or Lily's) wand.  Maybe to make a Horcrux you have to 
use 
> the wand of the person you killed?

You make an interesting point here. Hope Harry is NOT a 
horcrux, but sadly the thought has crossed my mind.

However, in GOF, during the priori incantem -- the spells the 
wand has preformed come back out: Cedric, the old guy, Bertha 
Jorkins, Lilly, and James. Right? What about the spell performed 
on Harry (which was supposedly AK)? Granted, he didn't die, but 
shouldn't a trace of this spell come back up?

OOOOH, will have to go back and re-read that part in GOF. 
Thanks for the mind-bender.

Marisa