Why did Snape react so angrily to being called a 'Coward' ??
jenniferstmatt
jenniferstmatt at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 21 20:11:18 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 133925
Michael McHenry wrote:
> Snape is protecting Harry.
> (begin circle-back logic)
> Snape is upset *because* the boy he is protecting for the cause he
> represents is calling him a coward in the midst of extremely painful
> circumstances.
>
> JKR wants the reader to doubt Snape to make Harry's anger look even
> more justified. Harry is supposed to love, not hate. My guess is
> that this will be a major theme of book 7. Anyhow, if Snape really
> was ESE, she wouldn't have revealed it in chapter 2, but at the
tower.
>
> Another theory: Snape has two tattoos. On his forearm is the dark
> mark. On his chest in two-inch high print are the words "Red
> Herring".
>
> -mgm
Jen responds:
Good point about how Harry is supposed to love, not hate, which also
brought to mind something I read in the recent interview transcript
on mugglenet.com about JKR saying that now "it's personal" between
Snape and Harry. How plausible is it for LV to somehow use Harry's
hatred of Snape to his advantage? To try to get Harry to come over
to the "dark side"? Snape becomes the object of Harry's
attention/obsession, he somehow corners a defenseless Snape
(contrived by LV), he draws on power that he could only access
through hate to hurt Snape, he comes to understand why LV and the DE
are attracted to the Dark Arts...then he remembers "Snape's Worst
Memory", his own past, all the things Dumbledore has said about Love,
etc., etc. - and he relents and repents and, with Snape's assistance,
overcomes LV. Or something like that. I must admit, I would love to
see Snape redeemed (or justified).
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive