[HPforGrownups] Re: Someone who knows why DD trusted Snape?

[TrekkieGrrrl]

No: HPFGUIDX 133950


"Cara" wrote:
> There might be potential for an explanation through Phineas.
> I personally am undecided as to Snapes allegiance, there are
> compelling arguments on each side, though I must admit that I'm
> hoping for a good Snape.
> Sorry if this has been picked up on before, there are so many posts
I
> can hardly keep up!

Cara, when I read that part originally in the book, I had brushed it
off as a snide remark from Phineas, but now, I think you are right!
Perhaps an unbreakable vow before Phineas?  Maybe not, pics don't
hold wands...do they?

Good going!

~Casmir

I still have this feeling that it was Hagrid that was the witness, if we're 
going for the "Snape and Dumbledore made an Unbreakable Vow" theory. Hagrid 
is backing Snape up ALL the time almost to the point of being a total echo 
of Dumbledore's "I trust Severus Snape"

So my guess is that Hagrid KNOWS exactely WHY Dumbledore trusts Snape.

~Trekkie