Snape in Daylight/Incomplete Prophecy

smilingator4915 smilingator81 at aol.com
Thu Jul 21 23:50:32 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 133981

Kristin wrote:
> > I am curious (i don't have the books with me) if we have ever
seen Snape in the daylight?
<snip>
> could he have some vampire tendencies?

>Dungrollin:
>Sorry to burst your bubble, but JKR has now shot this theory down
>*twice*.


JKR: (from Mugglenet interview, 7/16/05)
<I
<feel it's time to step in, because there's really nothing in the
<canon that supports that.

>Trekkie:
>Yabut.. I just don't AGREE that there's no canon evidence for him
being >a 
>vampire. On the contrary I think there has been so many hints in that 
>direction that I see red herrings swimming by when JKR responds like
>that.

I just read the interview Dungrollin mentioned that's posted on
Mugglenet. JKR kinda hurt my feelings there when she said the theory
was "off the wall" because there's no canon evidence. I agree with you
Trekkie, there have been many hints pointing in that direction. Maybe
we are thinking too big, and as you said earlier, the bat hints have
to do with Snape's patronus or transfiguration, not his blood line. 

Just my thoughts...

smilingator(whose feelings are hurt but still thinks JKR is a genius)







More information about the HPforGrownups archive