An AK Puzzle
M.Clifford
Aisbelmon at hotmail.com
Fri Jul 22 03:33:40 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 134021
Vivamus:
> > A. Did anyone notice that the AK does *NOT* blast things?
> >
> > What if, as someone else already has suggested, Snape did not mean
> > the AK at all...
> Merrylinks:
> Yes! Yes! I saw that, too. On the basis of the new Dumbledore
> portrait in the headmistress's office and because of Fawkes's
> behavior, I'm sure that Dumbledore is really dead. But the effect of
> Snape's AK was unlike any successful AK we have seen so far in the
> books. Dumbledore should have expired instantaneously, slumping to
> the floor because his legs would no longer support him, but with
> eyes open and with no change in his facial expression.
>
> It is unclear to me what caused Dumbledore to be blasted into the
> air and then to fall from the tower. Was it the effect of a
> partially effective AK coming from Snape? Did Dumbledore accomplish
> it himself -- which would make it suicide? (I don't like that
> explanation, but it has to be considered.) Does anybody have any
> other thoughts?
> Merrylinks
Valky:
Yep.
It also explains something I just not long ago today had pointed out
to me, that there was also some apparent evidence of the two
legilimens communicating silently with each other before it happened.
"Snape gazed for a moment at Dumbledore, and there was revulsion and
hatred etched in the hard lines of his face."
I need not point out again the hatred and revulsion were what Harry
felt too.. yada yada.. just assume I did to back my theory of the
legilimensing conversation between Snape and Dumbledore..
Dumbledore speaks aloud: Severus..
Dumbledore offers thoughts: You have to do it here.. it doesn't matter
we are running out of time.. make it look right..
Snape hates himself, is repulsed by what he has to do but...
Dumbledore speaks: Severus, Please...
Snape didn't do the Avada Kedavra. He Occlumensed everyone in the
room, spoke the words "Avada Kedavra" and voicelessly cast a blasting
spell coupled with a hover charm for effect..
DE's are impressed, It's over, Snape leaves.
Dumbledores last breath leaves him as he lays on the ground below the
Astronomy Tower. Fawkes heart breaks as he follows his masters strict
orders and refrains himself from crying.. he begins to wail in his
mourning song..
Curtain closes on Dumbledores last act.
Valky
Who, yes, *definitely* believes in WillingSacrifice!Dumbledore and
Innocent!Snape.
P.S. Snape later tells Harry how he did it, perhaps?
Blocked again and again til you keep your mouth shut and your mind
closed.. etc etc
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive