Harry the Horcrux

verysherryk verysherryk at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 22 05:25:33 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134057

Derek wrote:

> The prophecy said (by LV's reading) that either Harry would kill him 
> or he would kill Harry.  By making Harry a Horcrux, he would be 
> covering all possible bets.
> Because as long as Harry is alive, then LV can't be killed either 
> because he has Harry as a Horcrux.  But if Harry is killed, then LV 
> wins, because the "Chosen One" didn't slay him!

verysherry:  

I was under the impression that LV did not hear the entire prophesy 
and therefore did not know that one must kill the other.  

IMO, I do not think that Harry is the horcrux.  According to DD, he 
went to the house to kill Harry and use Harry's death to create the 
final horcrux. Also didn't DD mention previously ( I can't recall 
where exactly) that LV unintentionally passed his powers onto Harry?  
If he was indeed creating a horcrux, then wouldn't he be knowingly 
passing his powers on?  









More information about the HPforGrownups archive