Horcrux Harry Will Die!/Wizard Population

esmith222002 c.john at imperial.ac.uk
Fri Jul 22 10:48:06 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134098

Duffypoo said:

Actually, I am convinced of it.  I will be completely surprised if he 
lives. He will die to protect someone after he has finished LV.  
There will still be DE's in the fray (I don't envision a one-on-one 
between LV & HP). 

Brothergib replies:

I've always assumed that is what Snape's role will be i.e. to clear 
the path of DE's for HArry to have a go at Voldemort. Or maybe Snape 
will have to lure Voldemort to a final meeting with Harry (? the 
veil/ personally I'd just lock him in the love room and leave him 
there!!).

But clearly JKR always bangs on about the importance of choice! Have 
you noticed DD never instructs Harry, he always lets him make up his 
own mind/make his own choices. The end will obviously require Harry 
making some huge choice wrt Voldemort. Obviously a life/death choice 
(as with Lily) is the most obvious.

However, I am still not sure due to;
1) the last word being 'scar'
2) JKR's early interviews tended to suggest that she could continue 
with Harry, but she didn't think she would want to!!







More information about the HPforGrownups archive