Dumbledore's Last Act

desastreuse desastreuse at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 22 16:19:11 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134149

missy writes:

> Because surely, DD knew human nature enough to know that 
> once Snape killed him, it would severely dent his standing in the 
> Order.  So, unless someone in the Order does know that the whole 
> thing was a set up and isn't saying anything to counter all of the 
> accusations that are now flying at Snape, then no, I don't buy 
> that 
> Snape is the one that is supposed to help Harry.
> 
> And since everyone in the Order is currently buying Harry's side 
> of 
> what happened, I don't see Snape living through walking into 
> Grimmauld Place.

It is entirely possible, however, that DD stored some memories for 
use after his death, specifically the memories of his conversations 
with Snape about DD's own death, the Vow, and what to do after he 
has killed DD.  I don't think it's very reasonale to believe that 
Dumbledore--knowing he was not well--would not have made 
arrangements ensuring that Harry will have the information and the 
details he needs for success after DD's death.  To me, it is 
conceivable that DD would leave Harry so vulnerable, especially when 
he knows there is information that Harry will need if he is to be 
successful.

desastreuse






More information about the HPforGrownups archive