Buckbeak knows best

[ludmila souza]

No: HPFGUIDX 134176

inkling108 <inkling108 at yahoo.com> wrote:
> You may not trust Harry's assessment of Snape because he is
> supposedly biased by his emotions etc etc... but what about
> Buckbeak's assessment of Snape?
<snip> 
> And there's nothing like sheer animal instinct to cut through
> all the emotionalism and over-thinking humans (including
> Dumbledore, see part 1 of JKR's interview on mugglenet) are
> prone to.


Magalud's 2 cents:

Love Beaky, nothing against him. It was perfectly understandable animal instinct to attack the one who was attacking Harry. But it may have been instinct only, and one cannot expect beak - sorry, Witherwings - to understand the subtlety of a double agent.

So, I love Beaky, but I still put my money on Dumbledore.

Magalud



SnapeFest 2005! Segunda parte em breve
Orgulhosa keeper da voz sexy de Severus Snape e do seu sorrisinho sarcástico
My fanfic: http://www.geocities.com/snapesecrets