[HPforGrownups] The Cave and the Tower

Laura Herndon LauraHerndon at mail.clayton.edu
Fri Jul 22 18:21:33 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134191

Tonks_op wrote:

( the scene in the cave. DD drinks the liquid and starts_ what??  
Remembering something that is from his life, or channeling a memory 
of someone else's??  And what memory is it?
big snip
Is he drinking the liquid out of a pensive and someone's memory is in
it??  Who's?  
 


LEH replies
I really like the idea of the basin actually being a type of pensieve.
Could it possibly be that the basin refills itself with the memories of
the last person to drink the liquid?  Perhaps Dumbledore is experiencing
the memories of the mysterious RAB.  That obviously painful memory -
sounds like someone being crucioed to me - would certainly explain why
RAB was out to ruin Voldemort.
 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]







More information about the HPforGrownups archive