cryptic remarks by DD at tower + the Dumbeldore making a horcrux NOT!

[Chys Lattes]

No: HPFGUIDX 134360


> Valky (just wanting to mention two things from PS/SS.)
> 
> 1. The Astronomy Tower is the tallest tower of Hogwarts, very very
> high up, and the place where the Trio took Norbert to give him to
> Charlie's friends. 
> 
> 2. I think Jo made it very clear from the very first chapter of the
> series, Dumbledore does not make Horcruxes.. Slug says it's the
> darkest of dark magic, and in PS/SS Chapter 1. Dumbledore admits, to
> Macgonagall, that there are powers he will never have, I wouldn't
> hesitate to assume that Dumbledore Horcruxes were ruled out there and
> then.

Chys:

Unless he did it when he'd defeated Grindewald. It's possible he took 
the even to his advantage, even if it was dark magic, I think that was 
actually refering to the fact that a death would have to occur. Having 
done that, it wouldn't be too hard to use a spell to do it- how did he 
know it was a spell? Told Harry he didn't know, but I dunno.


*confused*