[HPforGrownups] Lily, Dumbledore, and AK

[rayheuer3 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 134417

 
Julie writes:
 
>Possibility 2:
>Lily did have to perform some ancient magic for  the rebound to 
>occur.  This protecting magic/charm may have been  "sealed" by her 
>choosing to die by AK.  The rebound on the caster  (LV) was because 
>of the magic, not just by her choice.  May or may  not establish a 
>horcrux.  (Horcrux being the scar because no one  else killed by AK 
>had a scar...it was surviving the AK and being marked  by a curse.)


 
Ray postulates:
 
  Forgive me for hijacking the thread, Julie, but this line of thought  must 
be set down on paper while it still makes sense (to me anyway).
 
1.  Lily performed some sort of silent spell (or perhaps she cast it  
earlier) that is triggereg by AK.  If AK is cast upon the target (Lily),  some sort 
of protective field is set up around a designated loved one  (Harry).  
 
2. Voldy tried to AK the target, and the spell rebounded, nearly  killing him 
instead of Harry, and giving Harry a mark representative of the  sacrifice.
 
3.  Dumbledore cast the same spell upon himself, the loved  one again being 
Harry (DD's love for Harry is that of a Grandfather for a  Grandchild, and very 
strong).  AK is cast upon Dumby, and now the field is  again set up around 
Harry.
 
4.  We don't know how long this protective field last, but if any of  the 
DE's present had cast DE against Harry, they would have died  instantly.  DD gave 
his life to ensure Harry would survive the raid on  Hogwarts.
 
  What do others think?
 
  --  Ray


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]