Snape's AK Failed!!!/Nagini as Horcrux/Lily's eyes

[snipsnapsnurr]

No: HPFGUIDX 134434

Justcarol67 wrote:
> 
> P.S. A thought on Horcruxes: I don't think they can be people, who 
are
> subject to illness, old age, and mortality, exactly what Voldemort 
is
> trying to avoid. I think it's supposed to be a solid object not
> subject to corruption, preferably made of gold. 
><SNIP> 
> Again, I wish I knew. But of this much I'm certain. Harry isn't a
> Horcrux.at


I completely agree with you. Maybe it is possible to make a living 
horcrux, but I can't see any reason for anyone to do it 
intentionally. If you are going to go to all that trouble to protect 
yourself from death, why would you make a horcrux out of a living 
creature that is guaranteed to die? I'm not even convinced that 
Nagini really is a horcrux, by the way. We haven't actually been told 
that she is. We have just been told that Dumbledore thinks she is.

snipsnapsnurr