Horcrux (Something of Ravenclaws/Gryffindor)

[Cindy]

No: HPFGUIDX 134572

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Lindsay <sunflowerlaw at g...> 
wrote:
> Wanda wrote:
> > No, this theory posits that Slytherin's locket never was in the 
basin
> > in the first place.  Voldemort put the false locket there 
himself,
> > when he first prepared the Horcrux, and Dumbledore is the first 
person
> > to find it.  How Slytherin's real locket ended up at Grimmauld 
Place
> > is not yet clear, but Regulus Black is, I believe, a red 
herring, who
> > has nothing to do with the Horcrux.
> > 
> 
> Lawless replies:
> 
> Interesting idea.  I myself wondered if the potion was indeed the
> Horcrux when we first read about it - however, if you look back 
into
> the earlier books, even to the beginning of this book, the 
handwriting
> of the RAB note does not match Dumbledore's writing.  They seem to 
be
> very particular with handwriting in the series - characters will
> always keep the same handwriting in each note posted to Harry.  Of
> course, Dumbledore could have changed the handwriting, but that
> doesn't really make much sense if he WANTS Voldemort to know, eh?  
(Or
> else why write the note at all?)
> 
> "ES: It seems like it would be impossible. If Harry had gone to the
> cave, he never could have done it on his own, it seems like.
> 
> JKR: Well, I'm prepared to bet you now, that at least before the 
week
> is out, at least one of the Horcruxes will have been correctly
> identified by careful re-readers of the books. "
> 
> By books, it would be assumed that she meant a book other than HBP,
> since that was the one they were specifically talking about at the
> time - so why put it in plural tense?  So the hint about another
> horcrux in the books leads to believe that it is the locket, since 
we
> only know about it, the cup, the ring (destroyed) and Nagini
> (possible).
> 
> But it is an interesting idea, nonetheless.  There was something 
about
> that potion...
> 
> --Lawless

That JKR, seven books, seven horcruxes (I guess technically six with 
Voldemort himself being the seventh bit of soul left).  It would be 
just like her to use the theme/title/plot of each book to identify 
the item/whereabouts/how to destroy each of the horcruxes.


SS:  Something of Gryffindor'or Ravenclaw/Gringotts
COS: Diary/Chamber of Secrets/destroyed by Baskilisk fang
POA: Hufflepuff's cup (Lucius Malfoy has to have his tea!)/Azkaban
GOF: Nagini/Graveyard
POA: Locket/12 Grimmald Place/may or may not be destroyed
HBP: Ring/Gaunt House/DD destroyed but we don't know how.
Book 7:  Voldemort 

Oi..the possibilities are endless.