Snape commits murder or Merely Unstoppers Death? (long)

eggplant107 eggplant107 at hotmail.com
Mon Jul 25 04:29:49 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134704

juli17 at a... wrote:

> He is determined that his death 
> happen in a way that it is most
> beneficial to the plan to destroy
> Voldemort. In a sense he is 
>"choosing" when and how he wants 
> to die. Snape reluctantly agrees
> to this plan,  

Snape sure didn't seem very reluctant to me, hate was etched on every
line of his face as he killed Dumbledore the instant he walked into
the room. And Dumbledore would be nuts not to tell Harry about this
crazy plan, he must understand Harry well enough by now to know that
he would dedicate his life to killing Snape if he murdered his
headmaster in front of his very eyes. As it is I wouldn't be surprised
if in Harry's mind killing Snape now had an even higher priority than
killing Voldemort; and if that was part of Dumbledore's grand plan it
doesn't seem like a very good plan. 

Eggplant







More information about the HPforGrownups archive