If Only Crookshanks had been around Snape//Audio Book

Danielle Arnt flyballcairn at bellsouth.net
Mon Jul 25 05:03:01 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134748

Then we'd know for sure, wouldn't we!! Crookshanks can tell when someone is not what they seem. Good old Crookshanks!!

*************************

I'm using the Jim Dale audio books for my re-read of HBP.  And I have to say that Phineas Nigellus' voice is completely different this time around.  This struck me as odd because I saw an interview with Jim Dale prior to the HBP release and he said he reviewed old tapes of each voice to make sure he did them the same as before.  Just nitpicking, I guess, but the voice he used in OOTP was dead on to the personality of Phineas, and this one is, well, not.  Sounds like any of his old wheezy wizard voices.  Disappointed on that front.

But Kreacher!!! Absolutely my favorite of the voices he does.  Just hilarious with his "won't , won't won't".  Got quite a kick out of it.

BTW, if you're thinking about the cd's, BN has them online for $52 free shipping, or $47 and change free shipping for members.  Probably won't last long, though!

witherwings









More information about the HPforGrownups archive