Would it be too obvious for Snape to be on EITHER side?

[zgirnius]

No: HPFGUIDX 134844

"lupinlore" <bob.oliver at c...> wrote:

> What would a "third option" look like? 

zgirnius:
Hi, I posted a possible interpretation of the events in HBP which meets 
your criteria a few days ago (Post 133503).

I've given more thought to possible motives for Snape taking the UV 
like he does since then. Maybe it's not simply a move to try and fish 
for information. I could also see a motivation comning from the way 
Cissy's distress seems to be getting under his skin. Either because of 
personal feelings re Cissy, or (even more speculative) if we buy the 
whole Snape was sorry becasue he lovbed Lily theory, because for him 
the circumstances of Cissy are hauntingly familiar. I would actually 
like the way in this case he would have boxed himself in to an 
eventual "hard choice" out of feelings for someone else.