Murder = splitting the soul?

[Floor Visser]

No: HPFGUIDX 135085

Morgan:
> 1. Does this count all murders? Even those done for a righteous 
> reason? If so, Dumbledore and most of the members of the Order 
> would have torn souls. Though, of course, the difference is that 
> they did not create a horcrux to save it in.


I thought you only split your soul through killing if you INTEND to 
do so. But I must admit I can't find any proof for this in the book... So, just my theory.

Floor