Losing fans for no good reason?

[l3al3y_Doll_3]

No: HPFGUIDX 135138

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "sienna291973" 
<jujupoet29 at h...> wrote:
> Now me:
> I can't help but feel that this comment was meant for people like 
> myself who had a different shipping preference from what 
eventuated. 
> But I think that I've personally done enough to try to present a 
> critic that is fair. It should be clear by now that it's not 
> about `fantasies being screwed with' but I suppose it's an easy 
> enough anvil to throw.
> 
> I just think HBP lacks the skill I came to expect from her and I 
> personally find Ginny's character development poor. And no, 
clearly 
> we're not reading the same books. An alternative question to ask 
> might be does a preference for H/G actually blind some people to 
the 
> flaws in that subplot?
> 
> Sienna
> Who's disappointed but not surprised that its once again being 
> labelled `sour grapes'


This comment was meant for people who in my oppinion refuse to look 
at the situation with an open mind, and over react in unnecessary 
ways. In the past week I've read several posts which were far from 
being fair- either to Ginny or JKR's writing abilities. I can't 
remember reading anything of yours, so if you say you've been fair, 
I'll have to take your word for it.

We'll have to agree to disagree, because I don't find Ginny's 
character development poor, nor do I find the relationship flawed.

*Rizza*