Ginny VS Harry

sienna291973 jujupoet29 at hotmail.com
Wed Jul 27 04:54:03 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 135164

LPD:
> I find all this Ginny/JKR bashing really interesting.

<snip>

LPD, I don't want to cause problems but I consider this comment to be 
vaguely insulting. It is not `bashing' to critic a writer, even one 
we're all very fond of, nor is it `bashing' to critic a character's 
development. I'm sorry, but I find the connection between our valid 
concerns and `bashing' to be unreasonable.

That said, I accept the examples you provided in your post. In my 
opinion however, they are too tiny and too infrequent to be useful 
predecessors to HBP!Ginny and this is nowhere better demonstrated than 
in HBP itself.

Sienna








More information about the HPforGrownups archive