Question about Patronus (Patroni?)
Inge
Elvishooked at hotmail.com
Thu Jul 28 18:23:59 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 135403
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Donna" <donnawonna at w...> wrote:
Please help me here. I always thought a person's patronus reflected
theirpersonality. If I'm thinking correctly, how could Tonks'
patronus change? If I remember my psychologycorrectly, a person may
change in many ways but their base personality stays the same, maybe
buried/suppressed but still the same. I'm thinking Tonks just may
not be "our" Tonks.
I know Snape said a persons patronus can change but, could Snape be
coveringfor someone?
Please, someone, straighten me out.
Donna
---
Inge:
Ah - this is what I've been waiting for...
Well, let's assume the patronus reflects your animagus-form - and
vise versa....
It wasn't really Tonks there with Harry - because Tonks was busy
elsewhere (infiltrating Voldemort's quarters in her metamorphmagus
changed appearance).
Someone else had to take over the Tonks-part (in polyjuiced
version) ... it was Sirius - well returned from his little trip
beyound the veil.
He he - that could explain *Tonks'* (well, Sirius') four-legged *new*
Patronus - and it would explain Snape's animosity against *Tonks*
when *she* delivered Harry to the schoolgates.
It would also explain why *Tonks* patroled inside Hogwarts. *She*
wanted to keep a close eye on Harry.
It would also explain - and this is my maingoal with this - why Lupin
was resistant to come out in the open and have this relationship
public.
Of course Rowling wouldn't give us a metamorphmagus in OOTP if not to
use her in the books to come - even in absense.
Ah well, the Remus/Sirius-shipper in me is happy again ;-)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive