A line of investigation.. Tom's Special places
lyraofjordan
lyraofjordan at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 28 21:12:59 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 135424
> Valky:
> <SNIP>
> > Are there other moments in Toms life that we know of that suit
this
> > profile too. They might be the places he left his other
Horcruxes.
> >
> > Any thoughts?
>
>
>Minervakab:
> I have been investigating this too. I have been trying to make a
> spreadsheet of the places, horcuxes, deaths that created them, then
> relating tham back to the seven tasks HHR went through in SS.
>
> I beleive the important places are Chamber of Secrets, House of
Gaunt,
> Cave, Riddle House, orphanage, and Godric's Hollow. That is only
six
> though.
{SNIP}
>
Lyra now
Perhaps I'm jumping to conclusions, but I feel this statement from
JKR's recent interview may be related in some way (tho how is another
question).
JKR: My feeling is that Phoenix is overlong, but I challenge anyone
to find the obvious place to cut. There are places that I would
prune, now, looking back, but ...(short snip) You need what's in
there if I'm going to play fair for the reader in the resolution in
book seven. One of the reasons "Phoenix" is so long is that I
had
to move Harry around a lot, physically. There were places he had to
go he had never been before, and that took time to get him
there, to get him away. (end of her comment)
So, she seems to indicate that some place Harry went in OOTP will be
relevant in #7. The "new" places I recall him going to are: #12
Grimmauld; the Ministry of Magic (includng the DoM); St. Mungo's; and
some places in Hogsmeade, where The Hogs Head would seem to be the
most interesting/likely candidate of the lot (somehow, I can't
imagine revisiting Madame Puddifoot's in the resolution).
Of course, the fact that someplace from OOTP will be relevent in the
next book doesn't mean it will be the location of a horcrux, but to
be thorough, I thought they should be mentioned and given at least a
cursory examination.
Lyra
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive