[HPforGrownups] Re: Your take on locket?

[rayheuer3 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 135492

 
Potioncat writes:
 
>I believe RAB put the fake!horcrux in the basin because I don't think  
>he/she could have gotten the real one out. And I don't think LV did  
>it himself because he would have known the horcrux was fake. But I  
>don't think the basin knew the difference. And it's very likely that  
>RAB wasn't supposed to know what the Locket was.
 
Ray replies:

 
  I like this.  It adds "facts not in evidence", but does not  conflict with 
any known canon.  
 
Potioncat again


>And if I'm correct, Regulus' body was never found. So he isn't  ruled 
>out as RAB. (yet)
 
Ray:
 
  I wanted to re-read OotP Chapter 6 "The Noble and Most Ancient House  of 
Black" before replying to this part.  Regulus' precise date of death is  listed 
on the Tapestry, and Black does not say anything about the body not being  
found.  Pity, the concept that Regulus is one of the Inferi in the lake  appeals 
to me. - But then, I'm weird.
 
  --  Ray

 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]