DD not like himself - Horcrux Theory

[diliapacheco]

No: HPFGUIDX 135499


> Snape saw in DD and what caused him to have such a look of hatred 
in 
> his eye was not DD, not the idea of AKing DD, but the part of LV 
> that he saw in DD. 
> 
> The main problem with this theory (and there are many) is while it 
> fits with the DD is symbolic of Jesus on the cross; it does not fit 
> with Harry in the CS.  Harry does not have any more of LV in him 
> than he may have had in the beginning.  
> 
> I don't know where to go with this and I have probably not said it 
> very clearly.  The whole idea is a bit complicated.  Any helpers?
> 
> Tonks_op

I guess, I would like to think that if DD knew something like this 
was going on with him, he would mention it to Harry, seeing that 
Harry was to help destroy the other Horcrux with DD. And even though, 
I tried to see the connection you made with Jesus and the cross, I am 
going to have to disagree. I am not trying to change your mind, 
because, I am just not in accord. The thing is that Jesus died as 
Sacrifice. DD did not die as a Sacrifice. There are rituals, and 
things I can't remember just know, that lead to a sacrifice. I don't 
know if you're following me, but Jesus sacrifice happen to save us. 
He pleads to his father, for our salvation. I am afraid it is two 
different things. Do you imagine that there would have to be 6 more 
¨sacrifice¨ in the 7th book? It quite does not convince me... Great 
imagination though. 

Dilia