Snape- New Theory

[Bhavna ( Impact Management, Mumbai )]

No: HPFGUIDX 135650

Hey Potterphiles,

Sorry for not giving credit if someone has already created this thread before but its really difficult to keep up with all the posts.

Its very farfetched I admit - but what if Snape is on no one's side? What if he is only on the winning side? He was a DE when LV was at the peak of his power - God knows how many innocent lives he took then - including of course albeit indirectly HP's parents ...when LV started losing his hold he conveniently scuttles off to DD and wins his trust ...now seeing that DD is slowly getting outnumbered by the DE joining ranks with the werewolves and dementors, maybe  even giants and goblins (unconfirmed as per HBP) - he switches sides again to LV saving his skin once again. He knows enough about both sides to get out of any sticky situation ...has enough information to use to his advantage on both sides !

If this theory is taken as true what would emerge is a shrewd but extremely selfish character - a complete coward since he does not have the back bone to die fighting on one side - the kind associated with Pettigrew but even lower and darker than him. This could also explain why Snape gets to mad at HP for calling him a coward - because he is one ...and you always get more angry when you know the other person is right!

What do you guys think? 

Bhavna




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]