Snape's Contribution to Deaths

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 135660

Nickel.said: 
>>My question is this: Is this just a lie that Snape told Bellatrix to 
try and convince her of what side he was on? Or did he really pass 
Voldemort information that led to these murders?

CathyD now:

He lied.  Just like he lied about not knowing Harry is a powerful wizard (parselmouth, patronus at 13, defeated LV again as QuirrellMort, defeated the basilisk/destroyed the diary).  Just like he lied by omitting the fact that he actually saved Harry during the Quidditch match.  

Others believe Snape lied when he said he knew what Draco's task was.  That he used Legilimency to read Narcissa's fears while he was looking out the window.







[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]