Dumbledore - is he or isn't he?

[Bunny]

No: HPFGUIDX 135730

I'd like to add my tuppenceworth to this debate:

1. I was undecided whether DD's death had been staged
or not, until I read JKR's interview in which she quite 
clearly states that whereas she was 'a little teary' over
Sirius, she was 'extremely upset' at the end of the Half
Blood Prince.
2. She's warned us in the past that we shouldn't trust
Snape too much

I wonder what the 'Draco lovers' think of him now.......
where he stamped on the defenceless Harry's face and
broke his nose justified what I have always thought of him.....yuck!
But even worse was when he was describing it and laughing about
it to other Slytherins.

In keeping with this, maybe if we stopped thinking of Snape as the
highly popular Alan Rickman, and thought of him as JKR describes
him:  sallow, greasy hair, yellowed teeth, grey undies, it will be easier
to believe that he's really evil.  Come on........the guy's really really
cruel and hurtful to almost everyone.

Bunny.