Ginny VS Harry / Re: HBP Review in Globe and Mail

coolbeans3131 joj at rochester.rr.com
Sun Jul 31 12:40:30 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 135769

 <drjuliehoward at y...> wrote: 
> I do not think she has failed.  I just don't think the romantic 
> pairings are as important to JKR as the main storyline.  She simply 
> can't include everything that all of her fans want to read.  IMO she 
> has made it quite clear these are not romance novels, so these 
> details will not be there.  They have not been there in the previous 
> six books and I doubt very seriously they will not be in book 7.  I 
> can understand why you are disappointed if this is what you are 
> looking for.  Unfortunately, I predict your disappointment will 
> continue. She has set up much bigger fish to fry in book seven that 
> who gets together and how.  If she departs from her genre of books 
> one through six and writes a romance novel for book seven, I will 
> join the ranks of the disappointed.


Joj writes:
I don't think any of us who were disappointed in H/G romance want Jo 
to write it as a romance novel.  My problem comes in Jo telling us at 
the end (with the Spiderman break-up) that Harry and Ginny have this 
deep relationship or love and that's the first we realize it.  Would 
it really be asking for too much to have ONE scene where we see Harry 
and Ginny connect on an emotional level?  

Physical attraction is an important aspect in relationships, but if 
we're to believe in this soul-mate senario, give us one heart to heart!






More information about the HPforGrownups archive