Lupin and Legilimency: Why Wait to Reveal?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 129864

Alla:

And now, my question, what do you make of the fact that JKR wished 
him Happy Birthday?

Pippin: 
He's a Pisces. Kind and wonderfully appreciative of others' needs.
But also  dual-natured, easily misled, great actors, fickle and
oft-deceived by their hopes.


Alla:

What is Pisces? Is it a personal name or just a definition for what 
you described? 

Thanks and sorry - language issues again. :-)


Alla earlier:
Is he the only villain, who had been wished Happy Birthday so far?
If  so, why make an exception?
 
Pippin
Honestly, I think you could get more out of analyzing the coffee 
grounds <g> Heroes aren't the only people who get birthday
greetings.


Alla:

Oh, of course it is meta meta thinking, but I thought quite a few 
people agreed that no bad guys  had been wished happy birthday so far
I take it you are not one of them then.


I guess I can continue thinking that Snape can be a villain in 
disguise. :-)

Thank you, I had been very curious to know your opinion on this one 
for quite some time.

Betsy Hp:
<SNIP> 
> I wonder if Lupin had a hard time forgiving Sirius for the prank?  
> So maybe it wasn't that James and Sirius and Peter moved away from 
> him, but he moved away from them.

Alla:

If Lupin was having a hard time forgiving Sirius for the actions 
which are not very clear to me yet, he definitely does not show it in 
the Shrieking Shack, IMO.

He is very dismissive about the whole thing, IMO. 


Just my opinion,

Alla.