Sirius and Prank again? Was: Re: Lupin and Legilimency: Why Wait to Reveal?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 129867



a_svirn:

And although I would agree that Sirius's actions and motivations are 
far from clear, two things at least are given: he did try to kill 
Snape and he did betray Lupin in the process. (Unless Lupin was privy 
to his plans, which I simply can't imagine). 


Alla:

I so don't want to open The Prank again, but these two things  are 
most definitely NOT given to me. I will send you links to some of the 
Prank discussions later, if you'd like ( I am away from my home 
computer at the moment), but the only thing which is sort of a given 
to me only of course is that Sirius told SOMEBODY how to get to 
Shrieking Shack and Snape heard it. We don't even know, IMO that 
Sirius said it directly to the Snape. Snape overhearing it seems more 
likely to me.
I said earlier that I absolutely cannot imagine Snape listening  to 
what Sirius said and believing it and DOING what Sirius told him to 
do.

Whom Sirius said it to, whether he said it in a staged conversation 
or not, why he said it, what was Remus role in the events and many 
other things are not clear at all, to me only, of course.

JMO of course,

Alla