"Some won't like it".

koinonia02 Koinonia2 at hotmail.com
Fri Jun 3 15:09:15 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 129987

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Message 129952  


Eggplant:

> Well
the fact is, Harry has done more to defeat Voldemort than 
> Ron or Hermione or Dumbledore for that matter, and he has suffered 
far more than they have because of it


"K":

Since we actually know so very little of the life of Dumbledore how 
can we say Harry has done more to defeat Voldemort and has suffered 
far  more? As of now we don't know that to be true. Sounds like 
wishful thinking.  ;-)  A desire for Harry to be the one and only 
great hero.


As for the "some won't like it" comment, I believe that covers a 
wide range of topics.

If you are a Ron/Hermione shipper, some might not like HBP. If you 
are a Snape fan, you might not like HBP. We all have our own pet 
theories and we all want the books to go in a certain direction and 
if that doesn't happen some won't like it. That's all. The author is 
just going to stay true to her story, as it should be.

"K"






More information about the HPforGrownups archive