[HPforGrownups] Re: About Lupin's boggart

[Meliss9900 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 129993

In a message dated 6/3/2005 2:37:39 AM Central Standard Time, 
willsonkmom at msn.com writes:
Just like the digalogue "part of 
a gang of Slytherins" told us Snape's House, but, except for that one 
time, it is never called a moon. Many readers think "orb" is a red 
herring, I think Lupin's calling it a moon is a red herrring
Ok I *know* that this is movie contamination. . please forgive me  .. but if 
that silvery orb were supposed to be anything other than the moon (especially 
if it was supposed to be a clue to something else) I think that JKR would have 
told Cuaron and Kloves that it shouldn't be shown as the moon.  We know that 
she told Cuaron he couldn't put a graveyard where the sundial was in POA (the 
movie)  because the Hogwart's cemetary was in another place.

I think that she would have corrected this as well.

Melissa


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]