Changing the title because I'm tired of it, was "Some won't like it". The Scar Connection Implications.

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 130060

Amanda:
I don't think Snape likes Harry, but I don't believe Snape ever set 
himself up as Harry's enemy.

Alla:

I believe that that is exactly what Snape did - starting since the 
first lesson, when he attacked Harry for no reason ( that is just me 
of course)


Amanda:
 For God's sake,Snape is a grown man with better things to do with 
his time. When Harry crosses his path, Snape feels no obligation to 
be pleasant, but I doubt Harry is in Snape's mind with anything like 
the frequency or venom that Snape is in Harry's.
<snip>

Sherry now:
Ok.  Now I have to say, oh come on!  We have been told that Snape 
hates Harry because of James.  Are you calling that a "grown man"? 
It's one of the most incredibly immature and ridiculous things I've 
ever heard of!  (I mean that attitude in Snape is ridiculous, not 
you, Amanda.)  To hate a child because of that child's parents, to 
have preconceived ideas about that child that you are not willing to 
release, that is not the example of a reasonable, emotionally 
controlled or mature individual. 
<snip>

Alla:

Ditto, Sherry! I can call Snape a being who is stuck on the level of 
emotional development of fifteen year old,if I am feeling generous 
but most certainly NOT a grown man.

Moreover, if before OOP I had some hopes that Snape indeed did not 
hate Harry because of James, after OOP I personally have no doubt 
whatsoever. Of course I can be proved wrong later, but 
Dumbledore's "some wounds run too deep" is very telling, IMO.


Lupinlore:
Not when the adult is a sadistic moron, you don't.<
<snip>
 
Betsy Hp:
I don't recall Dumbledore ever being referred to as a sadistic 
moron.  

Alla:

Betsy, I am not 100% sure of course, but I think Lupinlore referred 
to Snape as sadistic moron, NOT Dumbledore. :-)


Just my opinion of course,

Alla.