"Some won't like it".

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 130115

"festuco" <vuurdame at x> wrote:

> Nope, did not. Founded a society
> to learn defense. 

Yep, he did. Within months of its founding it was battling Voldemort
and his Death Eaters.

> He lived because of his Mum 

Yes that is true, he would not exist without his mother. Or his father.

> none of his doing. 

If true then none of Dumbledore's accomplishments were his doing
either, he's the man he is because of his genes and his environment
and he controls neither.
Just because you can explain why a person did a great thing does not
make it any less great.

> Saved thw world in book 1: nope

Yep. He save the world twice in book 1.

> In book 2: saved Ginny, did he save the world? Nope 

Yep. Without Harry Voldemort would have returned in book 2.

> In book 4: got out alive, with a lot of luck and help. 

He got out because Harry was stronger than Voldemort at magical arm
wrestling. Harry forced Voldemort's wand to regurgitate old spells not
the other way round.

> In book 5: got out alive because
> the Order came to save his ass. 

And also because Voldemort wasn't strong enough to posses Harry for
more than a few seconds, even though he'd shown the ability to posses
Ginny and even a Dark Arts teacher for months at a time.

Eggplant