"Some won't like it".
Renee Daniels
Calimora at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 6 01:17:49 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 130135
> Anyway, I hope we do see Occlumency again and learn more about it,
so
> we can better judge exactly how it is taught under more normal
> circumstances, and between a student and teacher who don't have so
> much baggage with each other. It will make it easier to more
> accurately judge just where it all went wrong in OotP.
>
> Julie
Calimora:
I do wonder how likely that is. One of the things that always
bothered me was how useful Occlumency is and how few people seem to
know it.
In OotP Dumbledore gives the distinct impression that Snape is the
only person avalible who is proficient in the technique, but that
doesn't make a whole lot of sence. If Voldemort could pick stuff out
of peoples mind's just by looking them in the eye then a Traitor in
the Order wouldn't have been such a big deal. Also, can you imagine
a Slytherin who came across the technique and its corrilary to not
study it?
As to an Occulmency instructor not having a lot of baggage with
Harry - Strike Dumbledore and probably McGonnagal.
~Calimora (Back from the Dead!)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive