Umbridge for Minister?
Derek Thorburn
dc.thorburn at ntlworld.com
Mon Jun 6 12:43:46 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 130162
Recently someone conjectured about Umbridge being Minister, as she was
under-secretary to Fudge. Personally, I don't think she'll even be
considered.
At the end of OotP, it is evident that the WW now knows and, moreover, is
convinced that Voldemort has now returned. After Harry was returned to
Hogwarts by means of the port key, Dumbledore promised Fudge half an hour
during which all would be made clear and he also told Fudge to remove
Umbridge from Hogwarts. In Chapter 37 of OotP, Dumbledore clearly tells
Harry that he has watched his career closely and, if he was watching the
scene from afar when Umbridge was about to attempt the cruciatus curse, he
would have told Fudge about this. If Umbridge went about her duties with
the attitude 'while the cat's away, the mice will play', I very much doubt
the Wizengamot would vote her as Minister. I personally think Amelia Bones
would get it. She seemed to question Harry during the hearing with an
extremely unbiassed attitude.
Derek
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive