[HPforGrownups] Re: Hogwarts' Cave

[Jazmyn Concolor]

No: HPFGUIDX 130621

John Kearns wrote:
>wizard-made, like the castle was built out over a part of the lake.  
>And I certainly always read it as though the stairs lead directly 
>into Hogwarts, though I was probably influenced by the movie (which 
>I saw before I ever picked up the book).  And this doesn't make a 
>lot of sense with the maps we've seen or with the idea that Harry 
>and Hermione can walk around the lake several times (if my image was 
>correct, they'd also have to walk around the castle).
<snip>  
>Depending on how many steps they walked, the cave might even be some 
>distance from the school.


The tunnel was created by magic obviously and thus doesn't have to 
follow the muggle laws of physics.

It could very well come out in another country or another planet if 
there was enough magic behind it...Passing through lakes, volcanos, 
anything at all... Use your imagination..

Jazmyn