Yet another prophecy question.

bbkkyy55 bbkkyy55 at yahoo.com
Sat Jun 18 02:57:25 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 130918

Okay, my brain is fried.  But let me think.  Now why do we have to 
keep the prophecy secret from LV?  Surely by now he's figured out 
that Harry is the one he needs to worry about?

Okay, he doesn't know Harry has powers he knows not.  But by now he 
must realize Harry is a worthy opponent.  Or does he just feel Harry 
has escaped all these times through dumb luck.  (which is a good 
theory really)

I'm wondering if indeed those "....and"'s in the prophecy do hide 
something.  Why did DD let Harry hear the whole prophecy?  Isn't DD 
worried that LV will be able to read Harry's mind and know it too?

Couldn't DD just have pulled out the part of his memory to put in the 
pensive that he wanted Harry to hear and left the rest?

Off topic.  Lupin cannot be evil IMO.  I really think he is next to 
die.  He's too tragic a character and doesn't have a real role to 
fill anymore, except to add to Harry's misery by dying.  

Got to go.  Help me if you can.

Bonnie







More information about the HPforGrownups archive