Emphasis on proper address was: Snape as father figure

phoenixgod2000 jmrazo at hotmail.com
Fri Jun 24 05:40:41 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 131344

 Insisting on a
> show of respect by Harry for Snape may be their way of trying to
> influence Harry to actually respect (i.e. trust) Snape as a vital
> ally in the Order. They may or may not know how hard it is
> for Harry--and how hard Snape *makes* it for Harry--to do this, 
> but I do think it is part of their intent. And Lupin's as well. 

You're probably right.
 
> Also Dumbledore usually corrects Harry at Hogwarts. Since
> Hogwarts is a boarding school, Snape's authority extends well
> beyond the classroom. 

DD's insistence on proper modes of address wouldn't bother me as 
much if there was any indication he was also putting pressure on 
Snape to treat Harry better. I want to know if DD is also correcting 
Snape in private to refer to Mr. Potter more respectfully as well. I 
just get the feeling that everyone seems to want Harry to go the 
entire way when it comes to Snape without Snape making any effort at 
all to keep up his end of the respect bargain.

phoenixgod2000







More information about the HPforGrownups archive