Question: Contest

Fitzov de Sullens kayt.williams at btinternet.com
Sun Jun 26 13:48:14 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 131465

MadameSSnape at a... wrote:
> Interesting - a dead felon as the Minister of Magic? 

tigerpatronus <tigerpatronus at yahoo.com> wrote:
> However, the person who wrote that entry did include a longer 
> theory of Sirius in their later predictions, saying that he had 
> faked his own death and, let's face it, if he had faked his own 
> death, JKR couldn't let on, now could she? 
>
> However, she does say something very interesting in this chat 
> (scroll down). Note that she doesn't answer the question about 
> seeing Sirius again (which means yes), does answer that we're 
> never seeing Regulus again because he's dead, and then doesn't 
> answer the question about the mirror (which means yes.) 
>
> Interesting . . . 


Now Fitzov:

Absolutely agree with you TigerPatronus.  I think JKR has been very coy on the subject of whether Sirius is dead or not.  As an ardent Sirius fan, it has continued to give me hope.

For what it's worth, I also very much agree with the person who thought the clasped hands on the Bloomsbury book cover looked like Harry reaching out to pull Sirius back through the veil; whilst the ghostly boat reminds me of the ferry boat on the River Styx.  The ring is also black, with some sort of pattern (possibly a column on it) and didn't Kreatcher try to rescue a golden ring bearing the Black family crest from Sirius during the 'cleaning' of 12 Grimmauld Place?

Fitzov











More information about the HPforGrownups archive