IMO, Sirius and Albus... /Veil sends back in time..

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 131511

 
> Chys:
> 
> Dropping in my 2 knuts here:
> Maybe they dunno he's really dead and just assume that you pass 
> through the veil to death? Maybe he's been sent back in time, to a 
> random time in history, and that would be why he seems to know 
> everything- one thing against it, why didn't he stop certain things 
> from happening- maybe he couldn't and not affect time up until this 
> point? *just playing around with theory here*

Finwitch:

I myself play with the theory that the Veil may well send people back 
in time... That it exists outside of time and therefore one can go to 
any time trough it.

However, Sirius Black does NOT become Dumbledore. For two reasons:
1) Dumbledore may seem to know a lot of things, but he does not 
understand *Harry* whereas Sirius does. (Hmm - Dumbledore tells 
Harry - and expects Harry to know well - that ignorance is worse than 
outright hatred. However, Harry's reaction shows just the opposite: 
Harry's staying away from Dursleys/'the rule number one for quiet 
life' - how both Harry and Ron saw Hermione's refusal to speak to 
them as an 'added bonús' - or how Harry found it a *relief* when 
Snape was giving him the silent treatment. As for Sirius - well, he 
was quite right about objecting Snape teaching Harry, about telling 
Harry all, about - well, even what Harry feels). 

Going back trough time you're to gain more understanding, not LOSE 
it! Besides, Sirius has Black hair and young Albus had Auburn hair. 
(OK, hair can be dyed by potions/spells, but still...) Besides, Albus 
has a brother, so that doesn't fit into that theory either.

However, SB might come back as a lead singer of Hobgoblins - Stubby 
Boardman. Quibbler has already made the connection, after all... 
(and, SB may have crabbed the rat, too) even though we get Harry's 
disbelief, and Hermione's snorting, and all the Snorkacks and 
Nargles... (Well, how do we know whether these things exist. Did 
Hermione believe in magic until she got her letter? We know Harry 
didn't) - well, each time Harry disregards something, it's important.

Yes, the Quibbler was - as a channel for him to have his story, but I 
do believe this article about Sirius may have more validity than 
Harry thinks...

Finwitch